Konsta Books

Guides

Severance Agreement Over 40: What the 45 Days Mean

By Konstantin Pokhil, PhD, MBA. Surgical oncologist trained outside the USA, not US-licensed, turned corporate exec. Not a lawyer. Last checked November 1, 2026.

General education about U.S. federal rules, not legal advice. Your state and your employer can change the answer.

If your severance agreement over 40 gives you 45 days, your employer is treating the offer as part of a group program. Federal law then requires at least 45 days to consider the agreement, 7 days to revoke after signing, and a written list of job titles and ages. That list is the part most people skip, and it is the part worth reading first.

The rule comes from the Older Workers Benefit Protection Act (OWBPA). It applies when the agreement waives age claims under the Age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA), and employers with 20 or more employees are covered by the ADEA.

When the 45 days apply instead of 21

The longer period applies when the waiver is requested in connection with an exit incentive or another employment termination program. Federal regulations say a program exists when an employer offers extra pay for signing a waiver to two or more employees. So it does not take a mass layoff. Two people in the same round can be enough.

If you were told you are the only one going, but you know of others let go at the same time with similar papers, that is a fair question for a lawyer. A paper that gives 21 days and no disclosure, in what was really a group action, may have a problem. The answer depends on the facts.

What the employer has to give you in writing

At the start of the 45 days, the employer has to tell you, in writing:

  • Which group or unit the program covers. The regulations call this the decisional unit.
  • Who is eligible, what the selection factors are, and any time limits.
  • The job titles and ages of everyone selected.
  • The ages of everyone in the same job category or unit who was not selected.

Age bands do not meet the rule. The regulation says bands broader than one year, such as "age 20-30", do not satisfy the requirement. Ages have to be shown year by year.

How to read the list

The EEOC's guide includes a sample format. A simplified version looks like this:

Job titleAgeSelectedNot selected
Accountant2435
Accountant4102
Accountant6310

Those rows are an illustration, not real data. Do this with your own list:

  1. Find your job title. Count who was selected and who was kept, at each age.
  2. Compare the share selected among people 40 and over with the share selected among people under 40.
  3. Ask whether the unit makes sense. If the cut was made across three offices and the list shows only one, write that down.
  4. If layoffs are coming in phases, the information should build up from round to round. Ask whether earlier rounds are included.

A pattern is not proof. Small groups produce odd numbers by chance, and an employer may have reasons unrelated to age. It is simply the first thing you can see for yourself, without a lawsuit, that tells you whether a lawyer's hour is worth paying for.

If the list is missing or looks wrong

Ask for it in writing, without accusing anyone:

"Thank you for the agreement. I understand this is part of a group program. Please send the written disclosure of the decisional unit, eligibility factors, job titles and ages, so I can review it within the 45-day period."

Keep the reply. If the disclosure comes late, a lawyer can tell you what that means for your clock.

Common problems to bring to a lawyer:

  • Age ranges instead of exact ages.
  • A unit that is smaller than the group the employer really chose from. Under the regulations, if the employer picked from part of a unit, such as the bottom third by performance, the whole unit still has to be disclosed.
  • Nothing that separates the people selected from the people kept.
  • No selection factors at all.

What a defect does and does not do

The EEOC says a waiver of age claims that fails the requirements is invalid and unenforceable. Federal regulations also say you do not have to return money before you challenge the waiver, and the employer cannot stop payments for that reason.

But be careful about what this gets you. A defective disclosure removes the barrier to bringing an age claim. It does not by itself create a claim for money. Many courts say that a violation of these rules is not a separate lawsuit.

The claim itself is hard. In Gross v. FBL Financial Services (2009), the Supreme Court held that an ADEA plaintiff must prove that age was the but-for cause of the decision, not only one motive among several. Separately, EEOC statistics show how rarely the agency itself finds cause. For fiscal year 2025, reasonable cause findings made up about 1.5% of the age charges it resolved, and about 67% ended with no cause found. Agency settlements and other outcomes add to that, and many people pursue private claims, so that figure does not measure the strength of any one claim. It does tell you not to treat "I'll file with the EEOC" as a plan on its own.

That is why the disclosure is useful in a negotiation. You are not accusing anyone of anything. You are pointing at a paper the law says must exist and be accurate.

How to use 45 days

  • Week 1. Calendar the deadline, your last day and your coverage end date. File for unemployment. Request the disclosure if you do not have it.
  • Week 2. Go through the list. Book a lawyer's hour and bring the agreement and the disclosure.
  • Weeks 3 to 4. Send your one email asking for specific changes: more weeks, health coverage paid through a date, a neutral reference, or a later last day that clears a bonus or vesting date.
  • Weeks 5 to 6. Read the final version again from the start. Check that anything promised on a call is in the paper.

Do not leave health coverage and unemployment until the end of the period. Those clocks are separate and they do not wait for your decision.

What to ask a lawyer

  • Is this a group program under the rules, and is the unit described correctly?
  • Does the list reveal anything worth raising, given how small the group is?
  • If I raise a defect, can it help me now, or would it only matter later?
  • Does my state add its own notice or pay rules for layoffs?
  • How does the WARN Act apply, if at all, to a layoff of this size?

Short on the 21-day version? See how long an employee over 40 has to sign.

Sources

Related guides